After sitting out 2016, the Audi Q7 returns with a roomier seven-passenger interior, a sleeker profile, and enhanced efficiency. The Land Rover Discovery, which technically hasn't been seen since 2005 – American consumers know it as the LR3 and LR4 – is also back in all-new form to tempt buyers who crave off-road capability.
Which of these three-row luxury rides does more to earn your dollar?
See a side-by-side comparison of the Q7 & Discovery »
What the Q7 Gets Right
The Q7's optional supercharged V6 engine takes it from zero to 60 miles per hour in a quick 5.9 seconds. According to EPA estimates, you can expect 21 miles per gallon in combined city and highway driving, a fine showing for a seven-passenger crossover with all-wheel drive. Towing capacity maxes out at an impressive 7,700 pounds.
The cabin reminds us of Audi's full-size A8 sedan. Materials are first-rate and carefully assembled. Road and wind noise are practically non-existent. With the second and third rows folded, the Q7 offers 71.6 cubic feet of cargo space.
What the Discovery Gets Right
The reborn Discovery is a brawny SUV in the Land Rover tradition of go-anywhere luxury. Every model gets full-time four-wheel drive and Land Rover's latest terrain management system, which can either adjust vehicle systems automatically or offers drivers a range of presets to setup the Discovery based on the conditions. The standard 3.0-liter, supercharged V6 allows the Discovery to tow up to 8,201 pounds.
While still formidable, the Discovery weighs 1,000 pounds less than the LR4 it replaces, and offers more refined on-road manners. At 85 cubic feet, maximum cargo space remains exceptional for a midsize SUV. The power-folding second and third rows can be activated remotely using the key fob or your smartphone.
On Road or Off?
The smooth and swift Q7 comes across as a luxury sedan that just happens to have the capability of a midsize crossover. It's a highly civilized vehicle that can handle just about any task most buyers will ask of it.
The Discovery is just as plush inside, but takes a different approach dynamically. Its top priority is off-road performance. In that regard, it has no equal in this class.
Our Verdict: Audi Q7
While we have a lot of respect for the Discovery, the talented A7 is a better everyday choice for all but the most adventurous buyers.
Land Rover Discovery vs. Land Rover Discovery Sport
BMW X1 vs. Land Rover Discovery Sport
Land Rover Defender vs. Land Rover Discovery
2018 Land Rover Discovery Gets Price Hike, Expanded Diesel Offerings
Smallest Land Rovers Get Performance Bump For 2018